The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

Investigation clears Eminem of domestic violence charge

Post and have discussions on the latest news from around the world.

Investigation clears Eminem of domestic violence charge

Postby DarkMan » Oct 8th, '06, 10:21

PUBLISHED: October 8, 2006

By Jameson Cook
Macomb Daily Staff Writer

Eminem was investigated by police for domestic violence for poking his niece in the head with his finger, and threatened to kill the girl at estranged wife Kim Mathers' house in Macomb Township.

No charges were levied against Marshall Mathers for the Sept. 24 incident in which the rap superstar went to the home because he was angry at the 13-year-old girl, who is under his guardianship, for hanging up the telephone on him, according to police reports from the Macomb County Sheriff's Office.

Eminem, 33, who is the midst of divorce proceedings with Kim Mathers, yelled, "I'll kill you," and took the girl's cell phone as he left the home about 2:15 p.m. that Sunday. Eminem also made a reference to Kim Mathers while scolding the girl.

"Don't you ever hang up on me again," the girl quotes her uncle saying, in a written statement to police. "The next time you do you won't have anything at my house and will never see me again. And you wanna know the reason I left your aunt was because she had hung up on me."

Investigators from Macomb County Sheriff's Office and county Prosecutor's Office agreed that Eminem's actions did not necessitate an arrest warrant for misdemeanor domestic violence.

"There were no injuries and nothing to give an indication of a domestic assault," Macomb County Sheriff Mark Hackel said. "We don't think there was any intent to hurt her."

James Langtry, chief of operations at the prosecutor's office, said Marshall Mathers did not receive any special consideration due to his celebrity.

"We treated it as any other criminal allegation brought to us," Langtry said. "There was insufficient evidence to warrant any criminal charges."

The girl says in the report that Eminem "was poking me in the head" and moments later raised his hand "as if he was going to hit me."

Eminem told police he "tapped her on the side of her head with this finger because she was not paying attention to what he was saying," said a report written by sheriff's Detective Sgt. Larry King.

Eminem on April 5 filed for divorce from Kim Mathers, 31, after less than three months of their second marriage. The two did not reach a settlement in the divorce case in a conference at Macomb County Circuit Court in September. The case has been sent to a mediator, and a trial date is scheduled for Dec. 19.

His 13-year-old niece, a daughter of Kim Mathers' sister, has been in the custody of Marshall and Kim, living with them at their prior address on Westchester Drive in Clinton Township.

Eminem's publicist, Dennis Dennehy, released a statement Friday night: "After an independent investigation by the Macomb County Sheriff's Office and a review by the Macomb County Prosecutor's Office, both have decided that the basis for the complaint was without merit, and the prosecutor has declined to issue any charges. Anybody who is remotely familiar with Marshall's life knows he is a caring and loving guardian of his niece."

Eminem is believed to be living in Oakland County but still lists his address at the Clinton Township residence, according to the police report.

Besides the teenage girl, at the home at the time of the incident was Kim Mathers' mother, Kathleen Sluck, 50, who lists addresses in both Ray Township and at her daughter's residence in Macomb, and Kim Mathers' youngest daughter age 4 or 5, fathered by another man.

Both Sluck and his niece say in their written statements that Eminem made the life threatening statement as he left.

Kim Mathers was driving home at the time of the incident and called police after being told about the incident.

Precipitating the incident was Eminem talking to his niece by phone about "her school clothing," Eminem told police. She "didn't like what she heard" and began "speaking over" Eminem before she hung up on him, Eminem told police.

Eminem told police he tried calling her back several times and tried calling Kim Mathers but got no answers. He said he went to the home "to make sure everything was OK over there," the report said.

Eminem entered the home without knocking or ringing the doorbell and went to the computer area, where his niece was at the computer and Kim Mathers' other daughter was on an adjacent bed. The 13-year-old put the younger girl on her lap.

Eminem told his niece, "You know she's saving your butt right now," the girl said in her statement.

He also accused her of being "selfish" and trying to break up him and Kim Mathers.

"You have always tried to separate me and your aunt. Always," the girl quotes Eminem as saying. "You take everything for granted at home. I'm signing shoes for charity doing this and that, and you're just a selfish kid."

Eminem took her cell phone, but it has been returned to her through an attorney and police.

http://www.macombdaily.com/stories/1008 ... m001.shtml

i never thought eminem was capable of doing what he did.. i mean, the way he raps about his family and daughter n shit i never woulda expected this... and even though his niece wasnt talking to him properly on the phone and hung up, or so it says, i thought he went over the top saying he will kill her... hmm.. he still coulda been affected by everything that was happening in his life.. but i dont know.. :unsure:


by the way.. anyone have any idea which niece it is.. i can only think of Alaina and Whitney?...
Image

Final Fantasy = Best. RPG. Ever.

http://www.afl.com.au
User avatar
DarkMan
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2296
Joined: Sep 30th, '05, 05:51
Location: the home of green and gold

Postby Curious » Oct 8th, '06, 11:30

it's Alaina - n as the article clearly states it's just an incident which has been blown way out of proportions (by an angry teen n an estranged wife probably trying 2 get back at him) - if he'd really done anything 2 harm u think the prosecutor would've let him off the hook? they would've swooped down on him like vultures

if the things he supposedly said r true some of them r really low blows but i can understand why he reacts, Lainie's a teen n teens can at times be quite... well, lets just say annoying - if i had a daughter n she'd hung up on me or talked back 2 me i'd be pretty pissed off too, that doesn't have 2 have anythin 2 do with what he's been going through n doesn't mean that he's got any less love 4 her in fact u could also say that it proves that he really cares...
Image
User avatar
Curious
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2037
Joined: Jun 17th, '05, 16:01
Location: Groupie heaven
Gender: Female

Postby Inzanity » Oct 8th, '06, 13:47

^^ I agree he was only trying to discipline the girl. She's lucky that Eminem adopted her in the first place because if it weren't for him her ass would be in foster care. She should apprceiate the fact that she's got an uncle who loves her enough to take her into his home. The way I see it she is selfish. He didn't like the clothes that she wears to school, so he tried to talk to her about it. She was probably wearing provocitve clothes like short skirts and belly shirts or some shit. And he told her he didn't want her wearing those clothes to school so she got mad and hung up on him. I would've beat her ass if I were him. It shows that he does love her because he dosen't want her wearing those clothes because he's smart enough to know that when a 13 year old little girl wears clothes like that she runs a risk of being raped. Now what if Eminem didn't do something about it. And lets just say that one day Alaina is walking home from school wearing a really short skirt and a belly shirt and some pervert drives by and sees the 13 year old little girl wearing clothes that a 13 year old shouldn't wear and walking all by herself and the pedifile not knowing that it's Eminem's necie or simply just not carin that it's Eminem's necie forces her into his car, rapes her and kills her or even worse lets her live. And the reason it's worse is because now she has to live the rest of her life suffering from painful memories of being raped when she was 13 and anybody who was raped as a child would tell u that their better off dead then living with the pain. There are people on this website who know that I was raped as a child and trust me the pain of being raped as child is not something u wanna live with. Now if that were to happen to Alaina that would make Eminem look bad because then people would say "oh if he loved her so much he wouldn't let her get away with wearing clothes like that." You get what I'm saying. It just proves that Eminem dose love her very much.
User avatar
Inzanity
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1642
Joined: Jul 9th, '05, 00:49
Location: America
Gender: Female

Postby ShadyxOne » Oct 8th, '06, 15:57

wait.... so thats actually true???
User avatar
ShadyxOne
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 463
Joined: Mar 25th, '06, 20:18
Location: Toledo, Ohio

Postby katastrophe » Oct 8th, '06, 16:22

wow...i highly doubt eminem did all those things to that extent. he probably got mad but i dont think he would threaten her :unsure:
Image

^^^Propz to McMaybe :worship:
User avatar
katastrophe
Under The Influence
Under The Influence
 
Posts: 4981
Joined: May 24th, '05, 04:20
Location: wherever my computer is located
Gender: Male

Postby claire01 » Oct 8th, '06, 16:46

seems like this got blown way out of proportion and doesn't sound like there was any need to get the police involved, wasn't like he was beating her up or shit like that
User avatar
claire01
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 433
Joined: Sep 22nd, '05, 21:09
Location: scotland
Gender: Female

Postby shady8 » Oct 8th, '06, 17:32

I don't think that story is true but it might be it just seems like a weird story. Plus i haven't seen the story anywhere else
shady8
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 103
Joined: Jun 13th, '05, 05:09

Postby Shadyluva » Oct 8th, '06, 18:12

THATZ WUT PARENTS DO, C'MON....ALL PARENTS TEACH THEiiR KiiDS DiiCiiPLiiNE, SiiNCE iiTS EMiiNEM, DATZ DOiiN DiiS, iiTS A BiiG DEAL...iiTS JUST BEEN BLOWN OUT OF PORPORTiiON
=]
lifee is GREAT
=]
User avatar
Shadyluva
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5260
Joined: Aug 12th, '05, 21:47
Location: new york ciity-->the bronxz
Gender: Female

Postby Shadyluva » Oct 8th, '06, 18:21

^^YEA...WHEN ii WAS LiiTTLE, ii USED 2 GET YELLED AT ALL THE TiiME, AND THE HANGiiN THE PHONE UP THiiNG, YOU DONT EVEN WANNA KNOW WUT WUDVE HAPPENED, KiiDS THESE DAYS JUST DONT GiiVE A FUK NEMORE...ME NiiETHER NOW ACTUALLY, iiTZ CUZ iiM OLDER AND MY MOMS KiiNDA LOOSENED UP, SHE DOESNT HiiT ME NEMORE, WE JUST ARGUE...BUT ALAiiNA...DATZ KiiNDA STUPiiD, ii THiiNK SHE TOOK ADVANTAGE OF EMiiNEM
=]
lifee is GREAT
=]
User avatar
Shadyluva
Band Leader
Band Leader
 
Posts: 5260
Joined: Aug 12th, '05, 21:47
Location: new york ciity-->the bronxz
Gender: Female

Postby TiFFany08 » Oct 9th, '06, 00:19

danigantt wrote:wow. :shocked:



i'm sure he didn't mean it, but it's still kind of funny to me though. :laughing:


I thought the part that was funny when it said he poked her in the head i mean cmon she acts like he beat her ass wit a belt or something
Image
User avatar
TiFFany08
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 1401
Joined: Jan 7th, '06, 03:20
Location: North DAkota

Postby ShadyxOne » Oct 9th, '06, 01:33

Blackheart wrote:who gives a fuck about this, it's his familly, he makin' music, we lsiten to his music, dont' need to now everything that's going on in his familly.



i knew somebody was gunna say sumthing like this. lol
User avatar
ShadyxOne
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 463
Joined: Mar 25th, '06, 20:18
Location: Toledo, Ohio

Postby claire01 » Oct 10th, '06, 04:56

Poor Em, he's had one bad year that I wouldn't even wish on my worst enemy.
Seems like Kims mum really has hate towards Em, Funny thing is, is she was a crap mother 2wards Kim when she was growing up.
Only thing Em did was tap Lainies head and say 'I'll kill you', well my dad has been saying that 2 me constantly out of anger, its a thing parents do, and I never hung the phone up on him, only hid his remote from time 2 time, he still says he'll kill me even though im a lot older now
I honestly think there was no need 2 get police involved and they should realise that he's going through a really tough time, and if anything , give him support rather than kicking him whilst he's down
User avatar
claire01
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 433
Joined: Sep 22nd, '05, 21:09
Location: scotland
Gender: Female

Postby hotcopper » Oct 12th, '06, 02:23

Posting after the fact on this . . .

I agree with just about everything already posted with just a few additions-

I believe that he did all of it just the way it was described and that's exactly what he should have done. Thirteen is a difficult age for any girl but especially one who has been pampered probably most of her life. She's not going to be anymore grateful than any other teenager at her age- no one should expect her to be; she probably doesn't think of herself as his 's far he'll go to discipline his kids- it's not just about forcing them to do something that they don't want to do for reasons that they don't want to hear and don't understand; it's about teaching them to respect you and maintaining that respect and protecting them from and teaching them about the harsh realities of the world as much as possible just as Empty Promises described (I'm sorry about what happened to you)
User avatar
hotcopper
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 184
Joined: Sep 14th, '05, 17:00
Location: Maryland

Postby Zowie06 » Oct 13th, '06, 16:31

he was only diciplining her .......here i got alot worse when i was a kid. :'( :smoking:
RIP proofXXXXXXXXX
Zowie06
Trailer Trash
Trailer Trash
 
Posts: 185
Joined: Oct 8th, '06, 22:02
Location: scotland

Postby ShadyGD26 » Oct 13th, '06, 18:13

ya eminem was jus bein a parent....like most of u I got it worse for stuff less important than hangin up the fone on someone so....they should jus let it go...lainie's a spoiled brat an I believe em's a good dad cuz u never hear this shit about hailey...
ShadyGD26
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 628
Joined: Jul 28th, '05, 18:07
Gender: Male

Next

Return to General News



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users