So which game has given you the freaks the most, has made you stop playing just cause you can't take it any longer or you've told somebody to stay in the room while you're playing?
Bioshock was pretty freaky but it wasn't scary in the way that I only jumped twice in the whole game, it's just the overall scenes are weird and bloody.
I think F.E.A.R. is scary, it's very silent and sometimes you don't expect the moment when the girl appears. I haven't played the expansions but they are meant to be scarier specially Extraction Point. I'll get F.E.A.R. Files soon cause it has both Extraction Point and Perseus Mandate.
They say Condemned is meant to be scary.
I've played the Jericho demo and it's not scary it just seems a bit like Bioshock (though Bioshock is way better), it's bloody and freaky.
What do you think? Remember there's a difference between SCARY & GORY!