Whos the best producer for Eminem?is It Dre or Eminem?

[ShadyVsEminem]

I am disappointed he isnt producing more than 1 track,i mean Dre is all around the best producer ever but i feel Eminem nails beats for himself better.I might hear Relapse and think what the fuck was i thinkin Dre`s the man?(or atleast i hope so)

The Eminem Show shows how under rated Eminem is as a producer because he gets little credit for his beats.People go on about Loyal to the game bein bad because of his production although i think he did a good job with it considering they are scraping the barrel with 2pac material and lyrically his albums are declining(Pacs life is whack as fuck).

[RealSickLindley]

I voted Dre because i love his beats. But i might've been able to say Eminem if the bastard didn't seem to make his best beats for other people. I mean for example, the beats for "Follow me" and "Crazy" on Trick Trick's album, which was late last year, and you could imagine him ripping the fuck out of them.

[ra1n]

I Like the songs that he produces himself better, he seems to put more heart and soul in them. Nothing to take away from Dre though. I just want to see more Eminem produced tracks on Relapse 2.
I.E.
No Apologies, The Way I am, Cleaning out my Closet, Till I Collapse, Sing for the moment, Patiently Waiting, Dont Push Me, Nail in the Coffin, Lose Yourself etc...

Eminem Production Discography:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminem_pro ... iscography

[Daveyboy]

I'm going with Dre even tho I hate his beats, Eminem just goes great with them.

Really Chet, you hate Dre's beats?!

[DelinQuent]

i prefer the albums where Eminem is the executive producer.

[slimsoxshady]

I've noticed that Eminem always has more serious/personal songs over his own beats, while he usually spits some Slim Shady stuff over Dre's beats. I think a mix of the 2 would be perfect.

[blitches]

dre beats are epic, just listen to whats the difference, the real slim shady, im back, my dads gone crazy, all dope.

[Xray]

Look at what Em's produced for himself

- The Way I Am
- Till I Collapse
- Renegade
- Soldier
- Say Goodbye to Hollywood

Are you fucking serious he made The Way I Am? DAMN thought it was Dre. Fuck Dre in that case, cause those songs/beats are Eminems highlights. Love those songs and yes Em > Dre when it comes to the type of shit he makes. His more of a dark producer where as Dre is a pretty much all over the scene. I love dark songs, and those songs you mentioned are my favorite except for Renegade. I can't believe he made Say Goodbye to Hollywood, that song is truly incredible. One of the best Em songs. I hate that Dre is making all the beats except for 1. But if its Dre he definitely has some hidden shit in there that might be mind blowing. We'll see in a few days time. Em > Dre.

[topdawgizalaw]

who produced superman?

[James R.]

While Dre is a great producer I wouldn't dare say he's the best, but that's just me. Anyways Em just sounds too good on Dre beats for it to be any kind of competition. I mean Dre just knows how to make a beat for the guy.

[theJFKshow]

The Eminem Show is the best album of all time for a reason.

[Xray]

The Eminem Show is the best album of all time for a reason.

Word up having produced 15 songs on his own album!! that's what the fuck is up!!

[Ella]

I Like the songs that he produces himself better, he seems to put more heart and soul in them. Nothing to take away from Dre though. I just want to see more Eminem produced tracks on Relapse 2.
I.E.
No Apologies, The Way I am, Cleaning out my Closet, Till I Collapse, Sing for the moment, Patiently Waiting, Dont Push Me, Nail in the Coffin, Lose Yourself etc...

Eminem Production Discography:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eminem_pro ... iscography

wow... new respect

[FDL]

Dre It´s One Of The Best Producers...

[Bank$terRapper]

i have to admit eminem is one of the most underated producers in the game, i wish he produced atleast 5 of his own tracks on the album cos after reading 'the way i am' he says that he crafts the beat to his own lyrics that he wrote before he even goes in the studio so that makes me worry that some relapse trakcs he just did off the top of his head which he supposedly did for a half of his encore songs