Beautiful Is Old?

[slimsoxshady]

listen to this track...Production wise. Then listen to say Deja vu. You can tell the track is old just from the quality of it. Track is still amazing and i could give a fuck less when he recoded it. Im just glad that we all got to hear it

Its not the quality of it thats old, its the fact that its Eminem production which was before the Dre Relapse sessions. Eminem layers vocals on his own tracks, he doesn't do it on Dre tracks.

Oh. Isnt this the song em produced by himself? Or did he only co produce on we made you?

Em produced Beautiful

[slimshdy313]

some of the shit he says in the song doesnt seem like it was made 3 years ago, but who knows

[CrazySheyD091]

listen to this track...Production wise. Then listen to say Deja vu. You can tell the track is old just from the quality of it. Track is still amazing and i could give a fuck less when he recoded it. Im just glad that we all got to hear it

Its not the quality of it thats old, its the fact that its Eminem production which was before the Dre Relapse sessions. Eminem layers vocals on his own tracks, he doesn't do it on Dre tracks.

Oh. Isnt this the song em produced by himself? Or did he only co produce on we made you?

so is déjà vu old too

[vermin]

who cares its new to me, and i love it.

[Robbie G]

I can see that, it definitely has a different feel from the rest of the album.

[slimsoxshady]

Deja Vu talks about his hospitalization with pneumonia (actually drug overdose) which was probably recorded last fall since it happened sometime at the end of 2007

[heva]

might be old but still dope as fuck

[Tash8]

to the motherfuckers that were to arrogant to read into my theory, here's the proof i was right

"Eminem recently talked about the song saying "There's only one song on the record that I produced. It's a track called 'Beautiful.'" [download now] Em continued in the interview saying "And one of the only reasons that I put that track on there is that I feel like it's the best song out of that batch that I did when I wasn't sober. At the time I felt like, 'This is it for me.' I wrote the first verse and a half in rehab, and when I came out, I finished it. It was the only song that marks that period without bringing me back to that place. Every other track not only didn't fit with the album, but when I listened to it, it would bring up bad memories.""

[slimsoxshady]

^^
props, so what are we looking at, 2006? anyone know when he was in rehab?

[JBM]

I wish we could have heard some of the other songs he recorded around that time. Someone needs to start slipping some shit into his drinks. Just kidding.
Relapse 2 will hopefully have some more of the serious songs. Two albums of this serial killer stuff would be too much.

[J Roc]

You thought that about No Apologies too.
You just think any good song thats new has to be recorded a while back.

hey dumbass 2006 is when everyone thought eminem had fell off, so him recording an amazing song back then, proves to me that he still has it in him and he hasn't fallen off...

jesus i can't believe this

"So him recording an amazing song back then"
So Writing Something in The Past Instead of Recently Prove's He Still Has It? ... What? ... lol He Still Has It , I Peeped The Track's It Reminds Me Of The eminem Show Level , Maybe Not The Same Kind Of Topics but Lyrical , Yeah ... That's My oppiniun.

[Tash8]

You thought that about No Apologies too.
You just think any good song thats new has to be recorded a while back.

hey dumbass 2006 is when everyone thought eminem had fell off, so him recording an amazing song back then, proves to me that he still has it in him and he hasn't fallen off...

jesus i can't believe this

"So him recording an amazing song back then"
So Writing Something in The Past Instead of Recently Prove's He Still Has It? ... What? ... lol He Still Has It , I Peeped The Track's It Reminds Me Of The eminem Show Level , Maybe Not The Same Kind Of Topics but Lyrical , Yeah ... That's My oppiniun.

people claim he fell off during 2006 but if he could make a track like this during 2006 then it pretty much proves that he hadn't fallen off.

[Evan C.]

people claim he fell off during 2006 but if he could make a track like this during 2006 then it pretty much proves that he hadn't fallen off.

Well, we know now that he never really "fell off", he still had the ability and intelligence to do good songs it was just buried under all the drugs he was constantly taking. If you're trying to say Beautiful really proves he was capable of making great songs WHILE he was an addict--I disagree.

Beautiful is sub-par in terms of rhyming in comparison to the rest of Relapse, and his voice isn't good on the song. It's OK overall because of the sample and production he chose.

[James R.]

Everyone fails. Tash wins.

Basically

[313]

Eminem said that this is old song! He wrote first verse when he was in really bad condition and second in rehab.
http://www.rapbasement.com/eminem/05120 ... -here.html