If Eminem had to lose one album...

[Relapse.LP]

If you could choose an album that was COMPLETELY removed from Eminem's career, which would it be? (It would be like that album never existed.)

I probably would choose Relapse, not because it's the worse album (Encore is), but because it doesn't really add to the overall feel of his first four albums. His first four mainstream records seem to tie in to each other, like sequels, and build up to Curtain Call: The Hits. Eminem would still be a legend without Relapse, but Relapse proved to haters that he still had the lyrical ability and the power to manipulate his flows like a madman: something lots of rappers can't do that easily.

[Relapse.LP]

I am not saying his worst album... just saying. Not doubting you.

[DaKidLilj]

Encore...i luv relapse...i wish relapse was darker tho but he closed out his first albums with Curtain Call so he now he has da chance to start fresh n Relapse is his fresh start...hopefully he follows da same route he did b4...n relapse 2 is like mmlp n then w/e is next is like Eminem Show...just hope he doesnt repeat Encore lol

[ShadyVsEminem]

Relapse is dark but with a twist.

Definitely Encore cause its his worst album and people who wanna discredit Eminem always bring it up.

[heva]

I wouldn't change anything

[DaKidLilj]

Relapse is dark but with a twist.

Definitely Encore cause its his worst album and people who wanna discredit Eminem always bring it up.

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

[Cyndi]

I wouldn't change anything

I would never take away any of his albums because I luv them all. This thread seems a bit pointless with no disrespect intended because we already know that mostly everyone will say Encore. We have so many threads on why they don't like it ---yawn--- Every album makes him who he is 2day So I wouldn't change it. I don't like Infinite, but it's not from his highly publicised career & it was the reason he was signed. So none.

[Jens14]

If I had to I would choose Infinite (assuming it's studio albums only).

[ShadyVsEminem]

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

I know what you mean alright,a few more personal songs would of been nice.He brought Shady back after about 8 years so maybe thats why he used that persona the most.

Ya i bet them Proof tibutes were atleast very good hopefully the unreeleased stuff gets released even if its after he retires.

[Evan C.]

Relapse is dark but with a twist.

Definitely Encore cause its his worst album and people who wanna discredit Eminem always bring it up.

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

No Apologies is from 2002 before he became an addict.

[DaKidLilj]

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

I know what you mean alright,a few more personal songs would of been nice.He brought Shady back after about 8 years so maybe thats why he used that persona the most.

Ya i bet them Proof tibutes were atleast very good hopefully the unreeleased stuff gets released even if its after he retires.

hell...if he ever does retire D we'll see with Relapse 2 tho...but Encore made him who he is 2...if u think bout it...ppl wouldnt b goin crazy for Em to come back sicker if Encore didnt suck nuts ...n tbh Encore had like 3-5 bad tracks

[DaKidLilj]

Relapse is dark but with a twist.

Definitely Encore cause its his worst album and people who wanna discredit Eminem always bring it up.

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

No Apologies is from 2002 before he became an addict.

really?...ouch...couldnt even tell...Em had me goin there thinkin he can spit nice when on drugs...well who knows tho...

[Jens14]

Relapse is dark but with a twist.

Definitely Encore cause its his worst album and people who wanna discredit Eminem always bring it up.

its horror dark...i was expectin life tragedy darkness...but im not complainin...i luv Relapse...i just kno Em is best when he puts his emotions in his music...n i wanna c dat again

i also cant help the fact that maybe his shit he did when he was on drugs may have been good...i mean no apologies, beautiful, Careful wat u wish for and my darling...all sick tracks!

No Apologies is from 2002 before he became an addict.

The lyrics of two verses maybe but the song itself is from 2006.

Anyway, what makes you (DaKidLilj) think that the bonus tracks were from his drug period?

[Evil-Genius]

Infinite , Sucksy ass beats , Boring slow flow.

[AliJack]

Infinite , Sucksy ass beats , Boring slow flow.

No, no, no, no, no, no.

The flow and lyrics were fuckin' amazing, albeit being radio friendly.

Lose Encore. not because the music was bad, because I personally have no problems with the album, but for his reputation, and because of all of the people who thought he fell off.