When I'm Gone

[robollama]

This forum is retarded........LOL

Half of the people on here are like, I want an Em track with some emotion and meaning and the other half are like I like his silly songs (Taking My Ball)......then when he comes out with either of these songs people always bitch about it.......God damn people make up your minds

....We want serious songs, but not forced with weak rhymes like When I'm Gone. I love the song, but it does seem a little forced... Just cause you like a song doesn't mean you have to all of a sudden ignore its' weaknesses.

[M-Pyre]

Lmfao at people hating on this track. It's easily best since the Eminem Show.

hahaha, no

[Emadyville]

this is one song it seems that all my friends who dont listen to rap or eminem still have on their itunes, it was one of those universal em songs like lose yourself that everyone enjoyed whether they liked rap or not, which speaks volumes

[embm]

its a gr8 song but it makes me sad everytime i hear it
dnt kno y

[embm]

^^
tru but its personal shit 2

[Drama Setter]

^^
tru but its personal shit 2

[Evan C.]

love this track, the hook is one of, if not THE favourite eminem hook of mine. amazing. and whoever said the rhyming was weak, that's just a lame thing to say, it was an emotional song, filling it with multies would've killed the emotion imo. the video is also one of his best videos.

and Evan C .. you're an idiot, he was quoting something his daughter would say, his daughter is not going to talk in multi rhymes, is she? no.

"I followed you DAD and now you made mommy SAD"

that is wrong anyway, it's

"You lied to me Dad, and now you make Mommy sad"

this is one of my favourite eminem songs.

Does that change the quality of the song any?

i didn't know the exact lyrics because I don't listen to crappy songs over and over.

[embm]

[quote="drama setter"][quote="embm"]^^
tru but its personal shit 2[/quote]

[/quote]

thnx

[shadybaby46]

i think the fact that half of you cant even figure out where hes rhyming in the song becaues he made the story so good should tell you that this isn't that bad of a song lol.

[M-Pyre]

i think the fact that half of you cant even figure out where hes rhyming in the song becaues he made the story so good should tell you that this isn't that bad of a song lol.

hahaha, no

[Robbie G]

eminem's best song since TES? Deja Vu, probably.

Yeah, I'd give you that. I think When I'm gone has a better chorus but they're about equal in my book.

[Wic Kid]

eminem's best song since TES? Deja Vu, probably.

You know, I still cant see whats so amazing bout that song. I actually forced myself to see it the way you guys do, but it just aint workin. I still think Beautiful is 100 times better...

[Evan C.]

eminem's best song since TES? Deja Vu, probably.

You know, I still cant see whats so amazing bout that song. I actually forced myself to see it the way you guys do, but it just aint workin. I still think Beautiful is 100 times better...

[Wic Kid]

^What? Am I maybe wrong for likin Beautiful more? If yes, I apologize. And you know what? Em is probably stupid for makin Beautiful a single. Like what does he know, right?

[Eminem4Life1006]

Loved this song just because of the story it tells and because it's emotional.