Mathers wrote:It will be impossible to call anything he does now amazing if you keep comparing it to his older work.
I'm not refuting that; however I do believe Eminem has it in him to release some aweseome tracks (GTC, Deja Vu would be examples for me of him nearing his earlier quality) and in any case, it's good to use his whole discography as a basis for comparison, but really the case now is whether he can better the music he has made since his recovery.
What this hook has shown is that he can maintain that calm, melodic voice without hearing it braking and sounding 'whiny'. Take the Reunion: i think that is a pretty dope hook (in comparison to the tracks released by him post-2010) but the way his voice cracks, it makes him sound whiny.
But in any case now I'm just being overly-analytical. From flistening to music, I believe that you can generally make your mind up on whether you like a track or not after, perhaps, half a dozen listens. I've listened to this a hook a few times now, and my overall impression has been considerably positive. I haven't felt this way about an Eminem feature (be it hook or verse) for some time.