StayWideAwake wrote:VINTAGƎ wrote:@Horsebot -- I think I'm uncomfortable where this is headed
@SWA -- Yeah. I have been lurking here since Relapse. Now that was 09, so a few years ago, maybe I'm remembering wrong, but I remember a lot of people not liking the content/accents. When Recovery dropped, most people were super into it. It felt more like Eminem's real comeback than Relapse. Flash forward to 2013, Relapse is considered one of his greatest albums period, and Encore >>> Recovery or Recovery barely >>> Encore.
I don't know why that happens. Or how it happens. My opinion has never changed on an album for me. From any artist. Once I absorb it, and feel what it makes me feel, that's it.
I hope, whatever the majority reaction is to this album that it stays that way. It's consistent.
Lets be honest, people don't want to admit that their opinion is so heavily swayed by others. Or maybe they just don't realize it and I'm being cynical idk. It also could be a case of "not aging well" which I know is a case made for Recovery. I thought Recovery was great. Still think it's a great album. Not without flaws, but objectively speaking away from Standards (see what I did there?) it's a solid album.
I must admit I brushed Relapse aside at first. It was before I went on this site though. I just wasn't crazy about it. Then one day, after letting it sit for a while...I decided to give it a chance since I was overplaying the rest of my Em music. When I put the attention into it and got past my first grievances I fell in love with it. If I would have listened to all of the hate I probably never would have given it another chance. Lesson learned.
My initial reaction to Relapse was a very positive and excitable one. But that was almost all because Em had been away for so long. Well, that and technically it was superb. But after a few weeks -- it's not that I liked it less, it's just the novelty wore off, and it became, for me, a very niche album. It is almost entirely dark, save for Beautiful and a few silly songs.
Recovery on the other hand, my initial reaction never changed. I loved it. Where some may see it as "inconsistent," I see it as versatile. I always felt there were two schools of Eminem fans. The ones who lean towards his violent, crazy, raw songs. The SSLP/MMLP crowd if you will. And the Eminem Show/8 Mile crowd that lean more towards personal, real, motivational songs.
I feel I'm in the latter, although I can appreciate his horror stuff for what it is.
And I think Eminem has this issue himself at times. Because he's so versatile, he's not sure if he should stick to one kind of feeling on an album, or be all over the place. As some have mentioned, his first three off this album sound nothing alike.
There really is in many ways an internal struggle between Eminem and Shady if you will.