The TRshady Forum became read-only in December 2014. The 10 year history will live on, in this archive.
Continue the discussion with the new home for the Eminem and Hip Hop discussion: HipHopShelter.com.

OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

All questions and discussions on Eminem to be found here.

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby BILI » May 9th, '09, 00:41

Great,excellent album.Yeahhhhhhhhhhh Shadys back.This is probably the best rap album in a long time.

Its waaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyy better then Encore and Infinite
Its close to TES and SSLP,but MMLP is better

Dr West(Skit)-Dope skit,its just like relapse of Shady

3 A.M.(7/10)-It would be 6/10 without that crazy video(The best so far,except Beautiful but its not really out yet)

My Mom(7.5/10)-Its really good song with cool hook

Insane(9/10)-Top 5 deff and it would be 10/10 but without this shit in hook "Is he nuts? No, he's insane

Bagpipes and Baghdad-(7/10)-Funny song but i expected some political song from this,but will prob get that on Relapse 2

Hello(6/10)-I just don`t feel this song

Tonya(Skit)-Nothing special,we had better skits but its leading to next song

Same Song and Dance(6.5/10)-Good idea but it coulda be wayy better

We Made You(6.5/10)-Not that good first single but at least its better then "Just lose it"

Medicine Ball(7/10)-Nothing really good and it kinda aint fitting in album,but just as a song it aint bad

Paul(Skit)-Its funny (I cant believe he made fun of C R)

Stay Wide Away(9/10)-HAHA dope song i like that thing with umbrella,and great hook

Old Time`s Sake(7.5/10)-I like this song and Dre did better job the Em in this one

Must Be The Ganja(8/10)-Very good song but the best thing in it is hook

Mr Mathers-This is dope

Deja Vu(8.5/10)-This is one of best songs on the album

Beautiful(10/10)-Great,great song best single and second best song on album

Crack A Bottle(6/10)-Not good song maybe I played it too much before and now its not that good anymore but anyway Fiftys verse is the shit,garbage this shoulda be on his album

Steve Berman(skit)-HAHAHHAH great skit,maybe best ever

Underground/Ken Keniff(10/10)-Omg this is the real thing i got wet on this song,best on album and at the and Ken its just awesome


Overall(8.5/10)
Image
User avatar
BILI
Pill Popper
Pill Popper
 
Posts: 9998
Joined: Mar 26th, '09, 16:05
Location: Croatia
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby slimsoxshady » May 9th, '09, 01:03

My Review....which matters more to me than anyone else's opinion :wave:

Dr. West (skit) - great way to start an album, really builds a story line behind all the crazy drug rapping.

3 AM - When it first came out, I was pretty content with this song. However after hearing the rest of the album, its a so so track. Unlike the other songs, the flow pretty much stays the same and gets pretty boring. FAIR track - 6/10

My Mom - I actually had my mom listen to this and she thought it was on point haha. I actually liked the weird accented hook. This reminded me a lot of Brain Damage and I loved that track. I thought it was funny how the second verse he rapped as his mom. I like that carnival beat with the tubas. First in a string of GOOD tracks - 8.5/10

Insane - Hook is great. Second verse is heat. That felching thing is not really necessary, that shits sick. The last bar "well this is called ass rape and we're shooting a jail scene" is a good way to end this 'very' homo song. I can see the mainstream audience buying this album and hearing this song and be like WTF? The beat is nothing special but fits the song. I'm down for the perverted shit but this might be a lil. Still like the song though, second verse and hook did it for me. GOOD track - 7.5/10

Bagpipes From Baghdad - Love the beat, bagpipes sound sweet. This song 'needed' as lil accent accent imo and it sounds dope. Rhyming is great. I still don't get how bagpipes relate to baghdad but whatever. The hook is unique, and it grew on me after 3-4 listens. Lol at "you're running over the snow blower with a lawn mower." The third verse about the lesbian conjoined twins is great. Beat is very unique and sounds great. Another GOOD track - 8/10

Hello - I've seen people hate on this song on here. This is actually one of my favorite songs on the album. Fuck Flo Rida, they should play this at the club. The beat absolutely knocks. One of the best hooks on the album imo, i like how he switches the rhymes up in the hooks (yellow and jello). I like the lines he ended each verse and that intro/outro repeat is great. This woulda been a better first single than We Made You. Love the beat, love this track. GREAT track - 9/10

Same Song and Dance - I immediately fell in love with this song. Its one of the softest songs on the albums but i love the story and its a nice change up. This is my favorite beat on the album, love that vocal sample in the background. Lol at Lindsey Lohan Britney Spear verses. Very chill song that i'm gonna play a lot. Dope hook, i love how he twisted this song to it talking about the last time his victims get to sing/dance is on this song. CLASSIC track - 10/10

We Made You - Well its alright I guess, it did grow on me but this isn't my shit at all. FAIR track 5/10

Medicine Ball - The beat is on some anthem shit. "All my West Side bitches throw it up..." line was funny and the "i had a vasectomy hector so you can't get pregnant when i bisexually reck ya" LOL. First verse is straight lyrical murder. I didn't like the hook, seemed a lil too self boasting and stupid sounding to me. Christopher Reeves part is funny but its pretty stupid after a few listens. GOOD track - 8/10

Paul (skit) - He never likes his albums lol

Stay Wide Awake - So many are praising this song, so no need to go too much in depth. Second verse where he rhymes entire bars is beyond crazy. First part of the hook is straight shittin on the industry without naming names. This song has soooo much replay value imo. HOOK - one of my favorite Em hooks. This song is nothing like Em has done before. LYRICAL SLAUGHTER. Slight accent but it sounds dope on this song. Beat is so haunting I love it. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Old Time's Sake - This songs actually doesn't sound too bad on the album. Good change up imo. It OK, not horrible like some people are saying. FAIR track 5/10

Must Be the Ganja - Everyone was shittin on this song when they saw it on the tracklist. Obviously they were wrong. Very good song. Unique beat but i think the snare drum is a lil too loud and painfull on the ears if you listen with headphones. One of the best hooks on the album that you can sing along to. Content is....idk, kinda sounds like Lil Wayne song (i dont mind Wayne at all though), self boasting at the beginning of verses. Very musical song though, great sound music wise. Would have made a good single. WTF is Interscope on? This shit woulda been popular imo. GOOD track -
8/10

Mr. Mathers - Sets up Deja Vu nicely, kinda like how the Kiss skit sets up Soldier.

Deja Vu - No need to go in depth because i'm gonna end up writing way too much. "eating 3 musketeers in the rear seat" i really liked that end line. Instant CLASSIC track - 10/10

Beautiful - If they promote this song right, it could be a big radio hit. I have to agree with a thread I saw that this sounds like a 2006 song. It doesn't sound like its from the Dre recording sessions (multilayer vocals are more of an Eminem thing on Eminem production). Maybe he should open up that vault and dig some more of these up. I enjoyed the crazy perverted raps throughout this album, but this song just touches another chord for me. Loved that "unfortunately I am, I just hide behind the tears of a clown." Nice sample on the beat, very chill relaxing beat. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Crack a Bottle - why the fuck would you put this garbage after beautiful of all paces on the track list? It was alright when it first came out but it got old quick. GARBAGE/ ALREADY HEARD IT ENOUGH SO I'LL SKIP track - 4/10

Steve Berman (skit) - pretty much confirms Relapse 2..nice

Underground - DAMN! This has those those rhymes that you write place (like facebook status, shit like that) Lines like "wack job in the back with a black stockin cap jackin off to a hockey mask at a boxing match." Chorus is epic, never heard that kinda shit from Eminem ever. Flow is different but its whatever, doesn't bring the song down at all. After 3 full listens of the album, I always replayed this song the most so its an early favorite. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Conclusion - I wasn't expecting this kind of an album at all. Blew me away the first time through. Sure, there are some rough patches, but all those are the songs that were already labeled as "singles." I think this is the best comeback any rapper has ever made the past decade. A lot of replay value. It's so damn lyrical, its unbelievable the words/phrases/entire bars he rhymes. I don't think the average mainstream radio listener is ready for this but the teenagers are gonna eat it this up no doubt. I'm not a teenager anymore but I'm very impressed and content with this album. I would put Relapse up against the SSLP anyday. For me, it even puts a few scratches on MMLP. Doesn't touch TES though, still my favorite rap album to date. And Encore what? Glad we can all forget that now.
Can't wait for Relapse 2.

Relapse 8.5/10
#ThankYouRapGod
User avatar
slimsoxshady
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10162
Joined: Jan 3rd, '09, 05:01
Location: 850
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Solace » May 9th, '09, 02:01

slimsoxshady wrote:My Review....which matters more to me than anyone else's opinion :wave:

Dr. West (skit) - great way to start an album, really builds a story line behind all the crazy drug rapping.

3 AM - When it first came out, I was pretty content with this song. However after hearing the rest of the album, its a so so track. Unlike the other songs, the flow pretty much stays the same and gets pretty boring. FAIR track - 6/10

My Mom - I actually had my mom listen to this and she thought it was on point haha. I actually liked the weird accented hook. This reminded me a lot of Brain Damage and I loved that track. I thought it was funny how the second verse he rapped as his mom. I like that carnival beat with the tubas. First in a string of GOOD tracks - 8.5/10

Insane - Hook is great. Second verse is heat. That felching thing is not really necessary, that shits sick. The last bar "well this is called ass rape and we're shooting a jail scene" is a good way to end this 'very' homo song. I can see the mainstream audience buying this album and hearing this song and be like WTF? The beat is nothing special but fits the song. I'm down for the perverted shit but this might be a lil. Still like the song though, second verse and hook did it for me. GOOD track - 7.5/10

Bagpipes From Baghdad - Love the beat, bagpipes sound sweet. This song 'needed' as lil accent accent imo and it sounds dope. Rhyming is great. I still don't get how bagpipes relate to baghdad but whatever. The hook is unique, and it grew on me after 3-4 listens. Lol at "you're running over the snow blower with a lawn mower." The third verse about the lesbian conjoined twins is great. Beat is very unique and sounds great. Another GOOD track - 8/10

Hello - I've seen people hate on this song on here. This is actually one of my favorite songs on the album. Fuck Flo Rida, they should play this at the club. The beat absolutely knocks. One of the best hooks on the album imo, i like how he switches the rhymes up in the hooks (yellow and jello). I like the lines he ended each verse and that intro/outro repeat is great. This woulda been a better first single than We Made You. Love the beat, love this track. GREAT track - 9/10

Same Song and Dance - I immediately fell in love with this song. Its one of the softest songs on the albums but i love the story and its a nice change up. This is my favorite beat on the album, love that vocal sample in the background. Lol at Lindsey Lohan Britney Spear verses. Very chill song that i'm gonna play a lot. Dope hook, i love how he twisted this song to it talking about the last time his victims get to sing/dance is on this song. CLASSIC track - 10/10

We Made You - Well its alright I guess, it did grow on me but this isn't my shit at all. FAIR track 5/10

Medicine Ball - The beat is on some anthem shit. "All my West Side bitches throw it up..." line was funny and the "i had a vasectomy hector so you can't get pregnant when i bisexually reck ya" LOL. First verse is straight lyrical murder. I didn't like the hook, seemed a lil too self boasting and stupid sounding to me. Christopher Reeves part is funny but its pretty stupid after a few listens. GOOD track - 8/10

Paul (skit) - He never likes his albums lol

Stay Wide Awake - So many are praising this song, so no need to go too much in depth. Second verse where he rhymes entire bars is beyond crazy. First part of the hook is straight shittin on the industry without naming names. This song has soooo much replay value imo. HOOK - one of my favorite Em hooks. This song is nothing like Em has done before. LYRICAL SLAUGHTER. Slight accent but it sounds dope on this song. Beat is so haunting I love it. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Old Time's Sake - This songs actually doesn't sound too bad on the album. Good change up imo. It OK, not horrible like some people are saying. FAIR track 5/10

Must Be the Ganja - Everyone was shittin on this song when they saw it on the tracklist. Obviously they were wrong. Very good song. Unique beat but i think the snare drum is a lil too loud and painfull on the ears if you listen with headphones. One of the best hooks on the album that you can sing along to. Content is....idk, kinda sounds like Lil Wayne song (i dont mind Wayne at all though), self boasting at the beginning of verses. Very musical song though, great sound music wise. Would have made a good single. WTF is Interscope on? This shit woulda been popular imo. GOOD track -
8/10

Mr. Mathers - Sets up Deja Vu nicely, kinda like how the Kiss skit sets up Soldier.

Deja Vu - No need to go in depth because i'm gonna end up writing way too much. "eating 3 musketeers in the rear seat" i really liked that end line. Instant CLASSIC track - 10/10

Beautiful - If they promote this song right, it could be a big radio hit. I have to agree with a thread I saw that this sounds like a 2006 song. It doesn't sound like its from the Dre recording sessions (multilayer vocals are more of an Eminem thing on Eminem production). Maybe he should open up that vault and dig some more of these up. I enjoyed the crazy perverted raps throughout this album, but this song just touches another chord for me. Loved that "unfortunately I am, I just hide behind the tears of a clown." Nice sample on the beat, very chill relaxing beat. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Crack a Bottle - why the fuck would you put this garbage after beautiful of all paces on the track list? It was alright when it first came out but it got old quick. GARBAGE/ ALREADY HEARD IT ENOUGH SO I'LL SKIP track - 4/10

Steve Berman (skit) - pretty much confirms Relapse 2..nice

Underground - DAMN! This has those those rhymes that you write place (like facebook status, shit like that) Lines like "wack job in the back with a black stockin cap jackin off to a hockey mask at a boxing match." Chorus is epic, never heard that kinda shit from Eminem ever. Flow is different but its whatever, doesn't bring the song down at all. After 3 full listens of the album, I always replayed this song the most so its an early favorite. CLASSIC track - 10/10

Conclusion - I wasn't expecting this kind of an album at all. Blew me away the first time through. Sure, there are some rough patches, but all those are the songs that were already labeled as "singles." I think this is the best comeback any rapper has ever made the past decade. A lot of replay value. It's so damn lyrical, its unbelievable the words/phrases/entire bars he rhymes. I don't think the average mainstream radio listener is ready for this but the teenagers are gonna eat it this up no doubt. I'm not a teenager anymore but I'm very impressed and content with this album. I would put Relapse up against the SSLP anyday. For me, it even puts a few scratches on MMLP. Doesn't touch TES though, still my favorite rap album to date. And Encore what? Glad we can all forget that now.
Can't wait for Relapse 2.

Relapse 8.5/10


I agree there with almost everything, cept Id give OTS an 8/10 and We Made You a 7/10.
Image
User avatar
Solace
Bad Influence
Bad Influence
 
Posts: 19901
Joined: Apr 25th, '08, 03:12
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Tash8 » May 9th, '09, 02:16

what's behind the tears of a clown mean?
User avatar
Tash8
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 12522
Joined: Feb 19th, '07, 20:04
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Throwback24 » May 9th, '09, 02:24

Edit:

It's actually a Mariah Carey Em diss rofl.

http://www.mp3lyrics.org/m/mariah-carey/clown/
Last edited by Throwback24 on May 9th, '09, 02:27, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Throwback24
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 937
Joined: Jun 28th, '08, 18:42
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby <Stiiccy> » May 9th, '09, 02:27

Btw did anyone else notice that Beutifuls mixing was wierd? not dissing it...i loved the way it sounded...just sounded really different

btw did anyone fuckin notice he uses autotune at the end of Bagpipes From Baghdad? hahahahaha
Sticcy Z
Prison in Febuary, i don't give no fuckkssss
Image
Saten is here
User avatar
<Stiiccy>
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3386
Joined: Dec 28th, '07, 14:48
Location: United States bitch
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Ella » May 9th, '09, 02:58

ppl on the internet fckn love the album and are still gonna buy when it drops
their fav track is def. 'Beautiful'... only a few haters
shit he might just sell amillie in the first week... =]]]
Ella
Renegade
Renegade
 
Posts: 2013
Joined: Oct 7th, '08, 10:21

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby slimsoxshady » May 9th, '09, 02:58

Tash8 wrote:what's behind the tears of a clown mean?

it's like, he's earned the reputation of being a comedian, so he tries to live up to that...but the real Marshall is hiding behind that funny guy, crying on the inside (behind the clown make-up and costume). Makes sense to me, it might not make sense to others though.
#ThankYouRapGod
User avatar
slimsoxshady
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10162
Joined: Jan 3rd, '09, 05:01
Location: 850
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby slimsoxshady » May 9th, '09, 03:00

Throwback24 wrote:Edit:

It's actually a Mariah Carey Em diss rofl.

http://www.mp3lyrics.org/m/mariah-carey/clown/

new?
#ThankYouRapGod
User avatar
slimsoxshady
Addict
Addict
 
Posts: 10162
Joined: Jan 3rd, '09, 05:01
Location: 850
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Throwback24 » May 9th, '09, 03:33

Way old.
User avatar
Throwback24
Soldier
Soldier
 
Posts: 937
Joined: Jun 28th, '08, 18:42
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Hadez » May 9th, '09, 03:41

how is "Beautiful" that high on everyone's list? :unsure:

it's good, sure, but the only thing it has going for it is subject matter. basically this song has what the rest didn't and the rest have what this song doesn't.
User avatar
Hadez
Under The Influence
Under The Influence
 
Posts: 4632
Joined: Jan 11th, '06, 03:42
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Hadez » May 9th, '09, 04:14

Eminemnow wrote:
it's good, sure, but the only thing it has going for it is subject matter. basically this song has what the rest didn't and the rest have what this song doesn't.


...Well, it's not my favorite song on the album. Deja Vu is probably.

I think it's good for its tone. It's not very lyrical but it's not meant to be. It's a soul-bearing ballad rap about fitting in and self-worth. Letter-splitting syllables wouldn't fit really.

I think it's one of his best songs. I like many of his songs for different reason. This type of song really has a mood and zeitgeist feel like Sing For The Moment to me. It's not as good as that song but it has a similar feel.

The chorus is cool too.

yea i feelin the chorus, he did good on it :y:
User avatar
Hadez
Under The Influence
Under The Influence
 
Posts: 4632
Joined: Jan 11th, '06, 03:42
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Xray » May 9th, '09, 04:27

shadyblue wrote:
Xray wrote:My review:

"Dr. West" (skit) - Dope
"3am" - Wack
"My Mom" - 50/50
"Insane" - Not bad
"Bagpipes from Baghdad" - Good (although racist).
"Hello" - Dack
"Tonya" (skit) - Dope
"Same Song & Dance" - Wack
"We Made You" - Wackest
"Medicine Ball" - WacK
"Paul" (skit) - Wack
"Stay Wide Awake" - Good
"Old Time's Sake" (featuring Dr. Dre) - Wack
"Must Be the Ganja" - Wack
"Mr. Mathers" - Dope
"Deja Vu" - Wack
"Beautiful" - Great
"Crack a Bottle" (featuring Dr. Dre, 50 Cent) - Wack
"Steve Berman" (skit) - Dope
"Underground/Ken Kaniff" - Crazy

Horrible album, I don't care what drugs he was/still on, no drug gives the right for an artist to make a horrible album about useless shit and degrade himself like that. Specially after we've all related to his previous albums so much. To me this was a cheap punch in the stomach.


possibly the strangest review of this album i cud imagine. i think you are the one on drugs, no offence. your opinion though..but i can't see where you are coming from AT ALL


Nah I'm not on drugs, I always expect an inspiring song, or a song I can relate to from any artist. Where as most of the songs on Relapse are childish, and like some have said and like Em said himself, his really broke inside his just scared to show it. And I think that itself is more inspiring than the songs. I like to benefit from songs and such, so songs like If I Had/Rock Bottom/Still Don't Give A Fuck/Loose Yourself/The Way I Am/Marshall Mathers/Sing For The Moment/Say Goodbye To Hollywood/Till I Collapse etc. are the type of songs I look to hearing on a Eminem album. This album had 2 songs that were like that, and to me that's horrible cause that's 2/16 songs that were impressive or inspiring. Most of the rest of the album had immature written all over it. Where as it was written well, but the concept was just a throw away. If he had took more time and released both of the Relapse's as a one...2 disc album it would of been better, cause Im sure there must be some inspiring or alot of inspiring songs on it. See how Beautiful was enjoyed by the majority and thought of as really good? why? cause it was real....it wasn't that Eminem that just talks shit, and acts like a kid, no it was a grown up Eminem.
Image
Over a billion Muslims, you could never stop Islam
Over a billion bullets shooting from the chopper's arm
Carry a motherfucker head that I shred in Nam
I speak literally, figuratively, the prophet gone


New Track: The Nightmare
User avatar
Xray
Pill Popper
Pill Popper
 
Posts: 9920
Joined: Feb 21st, '07, 04:37
Location: Australia
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby Xray » May 9th, '09, 04:41

Eminemnow wrote:lmao well Xray you're pretty much alone in your feelings about the album.

Even on hardcore rap forums who normally hate on em, 95% of them are praising nearly every track as genius.

If you don't like the album... Well, you don't - You've said so. So why keep coming back into the thread.


What your some type of Mod all the sudden newbie? I wasn't even talking to you, so why are you butthurt cause I called Eminems album horrible? My opinion stands alone? good, I like it that way.

Next time mind your business.
Image
Over a billion Muslims, you could never stop Islam
Over a billion bullets shooting from the chopper's arm
Carry a motherfucker head that I shred in Nam
I speak literally, figuratively, the prophet gone


New Track: The Nightmare
User avatar
Xray
Pill Popper
Pill Popper
 
Posts: 9920
Joined: Feb 21st, '07, 04:37
Location: Australia
Gender: Male

Re: OFFICAL **RELAPSE THREAD**

Postby <Stiiccy> » May 9th, '09, 05:31

i know where x-ray is commin from here...and i respect his opinion...i dont agree with it, cuzz i loved the album...prolly cuzz im immature as fuck..but hey we all have tastes
Sticcy Z
Prison in Febuary, i don't give no fuckkssss
Image
Saten is here
User avatar
<Stiiccy>
Role Model
Role Model
 
Posts: 3386
Joined: Dec 28th, '07, 14:48
Location: United States bitch
Gender: Male

PreviousNext

Return to Eminem



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot]